Operating an enterprise in a foreign jurisdiction is a business activity that is rife with potential pitfalls. Most often, foreign enterprises must abide by both the laws of their jurisdiction of origin and the nation in which they operate their businesses. Which laws apply and to what degree largely depend upon the circumstances, but suffice it to say that a breach of criminal or civil law in either a company’s home jurisdiction or foreign place of operation is likely to land the organization in legal trouble. But what should a Wholly ForeignOwned Enterprise (“WFOE”) operating in China do to avoid ending up in court? And if a WFOE does find itself before a Chinese judge, how can the company maximize its chances of winning the case?
Doing Business as a WFOE in China
Many Western companies with long-term plans for engagement with Chinese markets organize as Wholly Foreign Owned Enterprises. WFOES are the preferred vehicle for many international business activities on the mainland because this legal form does not require the same degree of local oversight and engagement as other models common for foreign cooperation in the Chinese economy. In addition to being largely autonomous, WFOEs maintain status as a distinct legal entity with all of the rights and obligations of personhood. This means that Wholly Foreign Owned Enterprises are able to enjoy both the limited liability afforded businesses and the individual rights offered under Chinese civil law.
China offers Wholly ForeignOwned Enterprises a substantial amount of freedom because these entities play an important role in the nation’s economy, particularly manufacturing and technologytrades. Even so, China watches WFOEs closely. The nation oversees many important WFOE activities under the regulatory purview of the P.R.C.’s Foreign Investment Law (“FIL”).The Chinese legislature recently updated the FIL and its Implementing Regulations to further increase the autonomy and decrease barriers to economic participation of WFOEs through preferential policies, thus inviting greater foreign investment and business activities.
Because they enjoy the benefits of autonomy, civil and regulatory protections, and other pro-foreign business policies, WFOE are a popular business model in China for anyone with a long-term plan for participation in the Chinese market. WFOEs are facing a generally positive regulatory environment, but this should not be taken to imply that WFOEs are afforded free reign. Notably, WFOEs are not treated as domestic businesses in Chinese courts. Rather, China’s civil laws carve out a distinction between domestic parties, foreign parties, and foreign investment enterprises.
China’s Courts of Law
China has enacted special laws and regulations to standardize the organization and behavior of enterprisessupported by foreign investment. Policymakers have built China’s legal environment to serve a dual purpose: encourage foreign investment and control the impact of foreign interests in China’s domestic economy. For example, China’s High Courts, which are typically reserved for appellate review, are the jurisdiction of first instance for major cases involving foreign parties. Most civil and administrative cases involving only domestic companies are reviewed at first instance by provincial courts and only elevated to High Court review upon appeal.
WFOEs can only be sued in Chinese courts, and foreign disputes have no time limitbut do impose special rules on procedurally significant aspects of litigation, such as fee-shifting awards.
There is no single piece of governing legislation that guides foreign civil litigation in China. Rather, foreign interests litigate their rights pursuant to the processes set forth in several laws, namely the Civil Procedure Law of the People’s Republic of China. Part four of the Civil Procedure Law particularly addresses foreign litigants in Chinese courts, and Chinese courts have supplemented the rules found in these sections with several guiding opinions. According to this portion of the law, “foreign-related” litigation is any dispute brought to Chinese courts involving a Chinese party and a foreign party or two foreign parties. It can even involve two Chinese parties if the legal relationship between them or the subject matter in dispute takes place or is located in a foreign country.
Even when foreign litigants move forward with cases following the Civil Procedure Law to the letter, there are often many potential complexities regarding the circumstances of the case and which laws should apply to the substance of the dispute. For example, contracts executed or carried out on the mainland are governed by the People’s Republic of China’s Contract Law. That is, however, unless one of the parties is of foreign nationality, the subject matter of the dispute is located outside mainland china, or some legal fact is present that establishes, changes, or terminates the legal relationship between foreign and domestic interests. Thus, anyone involved in a Chinese-foreign equity joint venture, contractual joint venture, cooperation in exploring and exploiting natural resources, or any othersuch contractual agreements should be prepared to litigate as a foreign party in Chinese courts.
Litigating as a Foreign Party
Directed by national policy favoring foreign economic investment, Chinese courts are growing increasingly accessible allies for WFOE’s legal interests. Even so, the circumstances that land a party before a Chinese High Court in foreign-related litigationmust be particularly favorable in order for a WFOE to have a high chance of winning its claim.
Over the past five years, only a handful of high-profile cases involving foreign interests resolved with a WFOE prevailing. Most of these claims involved labor disputes, such as the 2018case of Chen Haidong v. Coca Cola Shanghai. This litigation involved an employee’s claim to compensation for untaken annual leave after the WFOE terminated the employee’s contract. In this case, the courts ruled in favor of the defendant WFOE, deciding that the foreign-owned employer was not required to compensate the terminated employee for untaken time off. Similarly, in the case of Shanying v. Shanghi Hewlett Packard Co., Ltd., Chinese courts sided with the defendant WFOE and decided that the company should not be required to pay severance on the termination of a labor contract.
Overall, Chinese courts have demonstrated a willingness to decide in favor of WFOE litigants involving labor and employment issues or issues likely to impact international trade. In the case of GreenTree Inn (China) Co. Ltd., v. Jiangsu Zhonglai Hotel Management Co., Ltd. filed in 2016, a WFOE was awarded economic damages and attorneys fees after the domestic company unilaterally terminated its franchise contract with the WFOE but carried on doing business under the franchise brand. This case highlighted the evolving intellectual property rights WFOEs are experiencing in China’s increasingly foreign-friendly civil litigation laws.
Even as Chinese courts have started to open up when it comes to WFOE litigants in employment and intellectual property cases, foreign litigants seldom prevail in many other common types of commercial litigation, such as contractual disputes. Only one recent litigation involving a WFOE defendant, Nike Sports (China) Co., Ltd. V. Guangzhou Xieli Sporting Goods Co., Ltd., filed in 2014 that did result in a noteworthy judgement in favor of a WFOEin a contract dispute.Still, the foreign litigant prevailed on only one claim while its domestic opponent won several. Between the complexities of the applied law and the general difficulties of navigating Chinese courts, many potential WFOE litigants turn to alternative dispute resolution as a means of enforcing their legal rights.
WFOEs in Alternative Dispute Resolution
In China, most foreign-related disputes are handled through arbitration. Foreign-related arbitrations are largely administered by China International Economic Trade Arbitration Commission (“CIETAC”) in Beijing, Shanghai, and Shenzhen. The CIETAC has already overseen the arbitration of more than 10,000 cases, and this figure is on the rise. The body has built itself up as a respected presence within the international community, and today the CIETAC is generally well-regarded as independent, impartial, professional, speedy, and efficient. As a result, many WFOEs elect arbitration over litigation in China when they have the luxury to choose.
There are a number of strategies WFOEs can utilize to maximize their likelihood of success before the CIETAC or other arbitration venue. First and foremost, WFOEs should maintain robust arbitration agreements with all of their operational partners in China. Because the implementation and enforceability of international arbitration agreements is a matter left up to international laws rather than domestic Chinese policy, arbitration can be more of a level playing field for foreign parties embroiled in disputes that may weigh on China’s economic or social interests. In fact, arbitration agreements executed by WFOEs doing business in China often include “choice of law” and “choice of venue” terms that allow foreign interests to file claims under the laws of their home jurisdictions.
If a WFOE has suffered a violation of its legal rights under circumstances covered by an arbitration agreement, the WFOE files an application for arbitration rather than a claim for litigation. Even so, both litigation and arbitration involving a WFOE in China must comply with China’s Civil Procedure Law and other domestic laws that apply to the circumstances. The insight and expertise of local counsel in this respect is invaluable.
How Do WFOEs Win in Chinese Courts?
WFOEs embroiled in litigation in China’s courts of law can maximize their chance of success by engaging skilled, knowledgeable local counsel with knowledge of both domestic and international laws. Chinese lawyers experienced in helping WFOE clients navigate China’s legal systemhelp bridge informational and communication gaps. Any of these potential pitfalls can easily cause a WFOE to lose a legal claim that it had every right to make and by all means should have prevailed upon. As such, any WFOE facing litigation in China would be wise to engage local counsel knowledgeable in both western and international legal conventions and China’s legal culture.
IPO PANG XINGPU, with headquarters in Shanghai China, we have been helping clients from all over the world with their legal matters since 1992. We are a group of dedicated attorneys and professionals with expertise and experience in a variety of legal disciplines. Clients come to us “When Being Right Matters®”.
Usually I do not read article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very forced me to check out and do
it! Your writing taste has been amazed me.
Thank you, very nice post. https://anunturi-parbrize.ro/luneta-porsche-55.html
Unquestionably believe that which you stated. Your favorite reason seemed to be on the net the easiest thing
to be aware of. I say to you, I certainly get irked while people consider worries that they just don’t know about.
You managed to hit the nail upon the top as well as defined
out the whole thing without having side-effects , people could
take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks
Feel free to visit my homepage … mobile legends hacker
My brother recommended I would possibly like this website.
He was once entirely right. This submit actually made my day.
You can not believe simply how much time I had spent for
this information! Thanks!
my page :: mobile legends
This is a topic that is close to my heart… Thank you!
Exactly where are your contact details though?
Feel free to visit my blog; starjack
thanks for your comments, you can reach out to us via [email protected].
Hey I am so glad I found your blog, I really found you by
accident, while I was looking on Askjeeve for something else, Anyways I am
here now and would just like to say many thanks for
a tremendous post and a all round interesting blog
(I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to browse it all at the moment but I have book-marked it
and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do keep
up the great jo.
Have a look at my webpage: luxury holiday villas
Hi, after reading this amazing piece of writing i am too delighted to share my knowledge here with colleagues. Fianna Huberto Blasius
Some genuinely quality content on this web site , saved to bookmarks . Brietta Vin Bate
I have read so many articles or reviews concerning the blogger lovers however this piece of writing is really a fastidious paragraph, keep it up. Stacie Harwell Arleyne
As I web site possessor I believe the content matter here is rattling excellent ,
appreciate it for your hard work. You should keep it up forever!
Best of luck.
my site :: code [Beatriz]
I visited several blogs except the audio feature for audio songs present at this web site is really wonderful. Celina Rab Pappas
You made some nice points there. I did a search on the subject and found most people will consent with your blog. Connie Zerk Samuele
I am happy that I detected this site, exactly the right information that I was searching for! . Leandra Lion Anestassia
I pay a visit everyday a few sites and websites to read articles, except this web site presents feature based articles. Mitzi Ambrosius Gilbye
I have read so many posts about the blogger lovers but this post is truly a pleasant paragraph, keep it up. Modestine Charlton Borlase
This blog seems to get a large ammount of visitors. How do you advertise it? It gives a nice unique twist on things. I guess having something useful or substantial to post about is the most important thing.
http://www.xmc.pl
Keep up the wonderful work , I read few posts on this site and I believe that your website is very interesting and holds circles of superb info . Sophey Weber Harrus
I conceive you have noted some very interesting points , thanks for the post. Nichole Gearalt Jayson
Very few websites that come about to become detailed beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly nicely really worth checking out. Roselin Skell Easter
You have got very good information in this article. Allsun Parry Shanahan
I am perpetually thought about this, thanks for putting up. Katie Nicko Olethea
My brother suggested I might like this blog. He was entirely
right. This post actually made my day. You can not imagine simply how
much time I had spent for this info! Thanks!
Here is my web blog :: 9 eleven
I have been reading out a few of your stories and i can claim pretty nice stuff. I will make sure to bookmark your website. Ginnifer Wilmer Marsiella
Wow, this article is pleasant, my sister is analyzing such things, thus
I am going to convey her.
Feel free to surf to my blog post … 9eleven
These are truly great ideas in concerning blogging. You have touched some good things here. Any way keep up wrinting. Amargo Sloan Outhe
Heya i am for the first time here. I came across this board and
I find It really useful & it helped me out much. I hope to give
something back and aid others like you aided me.
Visit my website; top-10-credit-repair-companies-2016
I every time emailed this web site post page to all my associates, because if like to read it after that my links will too. Arlana Rocky Barbour
This is very interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your rss feed and look forward to seeking more of your magnificent post.
Also, I have shared your website in my social networks!
my blog :: xxx tube
I am regular reader, how are you everybody? This piece of writing posted at this web site is genuinely fastidious. Babette Pepillo Oralee
Thanks for your interest in our blogs, we will keep updating new blogs.
Hurrah! At last I got a webpage from where I be capable of genuinely take useful data concerning my study and knowledge. Lindy Kristoforo Hayes
Hi there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to look it over. Rivkah Clement Milton
I visited several web sites however the audio feature for audio songs present at this web site is in fact wonderful. Berenice Darin Skiba
Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Many thanks, However I am encountering troubles with your RSS. Cornelle Bondon Ocker
Glad to be one of several visitants on this awful internet site : D. Peg Elliot Denae
Woah! I’m really digging the template/theme of this blog. It’s simple, yet effective.
A lot of times it’s tough to get that “perfect balance” between superb
usability and visual appeal. I must say you’ve done a great job with this.
In addition, the blog loads extremely fast for me on Firefox.
Exceptional Blog!
Feel free to surf to my page: комплект камер видеонаблюдения